Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 12:51 pm  

i dont think we do ye we got holdsworth but aswell we have ratchford he not been up to much this season but dont forget he has been injured and hasnt had many 1st team appearances due to injury... there partnership next year will rock

Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 1:02 pm  

The Original Red Devils wrote:

And how many game have you seen Dan play in? You cant base your argument on Salford's league position he has bin injured half of it, and doesn't have the players around him other teams do. Dan Holdsworth is a class act. I Would prefer obst over smith though.

Has anyone considered that Dan may want Smith as his regular halves partner? He may want a regular no thrills Scrum Half beside him rather than someone like Ratchford who plays more off the cuff and thus is less readable for him.

Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 2:07 pm  

The Original Red Devils wrote:

And how many game have you seen Dan play in? You cant base your argument on Salford's league position he has bin injured half of it, and doesn't have the players around him other teams do. Dan Holdsworth is a class act. I Would prefer obst over smith though.

smith is a bag of s***e and belongs in the lower leagues, and 7/8 games thanks... long enough to see him play cr*p, should of kept robbie paul over smith

im not a salford fan so 7/8 games is enough

Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 2:32 pm  

This topic is about who is coming back to Salford to Play for us , Do you reckon It's Robbie ?

As to the merits of our half backs this year it's safe to say Holdsworth is ' special ' .
Overall Matty Smith has made a postive contribution , He certainly has with the club & coaching staff otherwise he wouldn't have been offered a full time contract .

Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 2:36 pm  

middleman wrote:

This topic is about who is coming back to Salford to Play for us , Do you reckon It's Robbie ?

As to the merits of our half backs this year it's safe to say Holdsworth is ' special ' .
Overall Matty Smith has made a positive contribution , He certainly has with the club & coaching staff otherwise he wouldn't have been offered a full time contract .

I could see Paul coming back in a coaching capacity but not in a playing one.
Smith for me hasn't done a great deal wrong, OK he isn't Gregory or anyone of that ilk but he has formed a good working partnership with someone we all agree is a very special player. There's no point in having the best 2 halves in the world if they don't like or want to play for/or with each other.

Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 2:45 pm  

i actually think as ratchford get older and gets more game time it will be holdsworth and ratchford at halfback with smith on the bench cos he can play 9 aswell just hope they stay injury free next season

Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 2:47 pm  

As far as I'm concerned Robbie Paul can get on the 1st plane back to wherever he came from. I've got no time for him whatsoever.

Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 3:44 pm  

middleman wrote:

This topic is about who is coming back to Salford to Play for us , Do you reckon It's Robbie ?

As to the merits of our half backs this year it's safe to say Holdsworth is ' special ' .
Overall Matty Smith has made a postive contribution , He certainly has with the club & coaching staff otherwise he wouldn't have been offered a full time contract .

I have been a bit disappointed with Matty Smith to be honest. He had that superb game against Saints at home but other than that he's been average.
I wonder if he has a motivational problem and got up for the Saints game because they rejected him?

Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 4:03 pm  

Daryl D wrote:

smith is a bag of s***e and belongs in the lower leagues, and 7/8 games thanks... long enough to see him play cr*p, should of kept robbie paul over smith

im not a salford fan so 7/8 games is enough

WOOOSHH

I agree Smith is shi*te i was asking how many games have you seen Dan Holdsworth play crap in?

Re: he is coming : Thu Aug 19, 2010 5:15 pm  

Steve McCormack has just left Barrow with immediate effect, could he be the one returning???