: Tue Feb 17, 2009 1:01 pm  

My top 8

1. Melbourne - even with a weaker squad - still a core of great players
2. Manley - best pack in the league - average backline
3. Brisbane - if they can keep Lockyear fit and Folau - exciting combo if they gel
4. St George - Bennett effect
5. Cronulla - dull but effective - let's hope Setanta pass them by
6. Parramatta - new coach new atmosphere can only be good
7. Roosters - showed glimses of what they can do Fittler can only improve
8. West - dark horses if they can keep Marshall on the field.

Of the rest
Titans - Prince apart not a lot to offer and lack depth
Bulldogs - not one decent player in positions 1,6,7,9,13 - wooden spoon
Penrith - lack of progress under Elliott caused by in-fighting will show they were a 2 season flash in the pan
Cowboys - lack of quality outside of Thurston and Bowen will kill them once again
South Sydney - could be knocking on the door for the 8 - Taylor has surely learned something from last year
Warriors - an enigma, capable of beating anyone on their day - just their day is too infrequent
Newcastle - never rated Smith - control freak who has seldom added value in recent years.
Canberra - one season wonders who like Wests 3 years ago will be sunk without a trace

: Tue Feb 17, 2009 2:17 pm  

you under rate the warriors

: Tue Feb 17, 2009 7:08 pm  

Eccleshill Rhino wrote:

My top 8

1. Melbourne - even with a weaker squad - still a core of great players
2. Manley - best pack in the league - average backline
3. Brisbane - if they can keep Lockyear fit and Folau - exciting combo if they gel
4. St George - Bennett effect
5. Cronulla - dull but effective - let's hope Setanta pass them by
6. Parramatta - new coach new atmosphere can only be good
7. Roosters - showed glimses of what they can do Fittler can only improve
8. West - dark horses if they can keep Marshall on the field.

Of the rest
Titans - Prince apart not a lot to offer and lack depth
Bulldogs - not one decent player in positions 1,6,7,9,13 - wooden spoon
Penrith - lack of progress under Elliott caused by in-fighting will show they were a 2 season flash in the pan
Cowboys - lack of quality outside of Thurston and Bowen will kill them once again
South Sydney - could be knocking on the door for the 8 - Taylor has surely learned something from last year
Warriors - an enigma, capable of beating anyone on their day - just their day is too infrequent
Newcastle - never rated Smith - control freak who has seldom added value in recent years.
Canberra - one season wonders who like Wests 3 years ago will be sunk without a trace

the closest the tigers will get to the top 8 is before the season starts.

the rest of it isnt far off the mark, except broncos

: Wed Feb 18, 2009 8:28 am  

fredie wrote:

you under rate the warriors

As I said they are an enigma - time will tell

: Wed Feb 18, 2009 8:44 am  

Eccleshill Rhino wrote:

As I said they are an enigma - time will tell

Warriors could be hit and miss because they have lost a lot of forwards like Wiki, Rapira and Swann. However they have signed Denan Kemp and got Stacy Jones back so they should score more tries.

: Thu Feb 19, 2009 8:40 pm  

No1_Saints _Fan wrote:

Warriors could be hit and miss because they have lost a lot of forwards like Wiki, Rapira and Swann. However they have signed Denan Kemp and got Stacy Jones back so they should score more tries.

If the NRL is as tough as everyone says Jones should not last 20 minutes - a real backward step

: Thu Feb 19, 2009 9:57 pm  

Eccleshill Rhino wrote:

If the NRL is as tough as everyone says Jones should not last 20 minutes - a real backward step

hes doing pre season training.

if he can get through that the NRL will be a walk in the park

: Sun Feb 22, 2009 12:14 am  

No1_Saints _Fan wrote:

Warriors could be hit and miss because they have lost a lot of forwards like Wiki, Rapira and Swann. However they have signed Denan Kemp and got Stacy Jones back so they should score more tries.

Again, where did they lose Rapira to?

He played in last week's trial versus Melbourne. I think you're confusing him with his brother from the Under 20's 2008 team, Steve, who has now gone to North Queensland. Sam, the Kiwis test prop is still with the Warriors.

Swann was hopeless for the last 18 months, and Wiki was running on about 50% for the last half of his contract. He got dropped midway through last season as a result.

: Sun Feb 22, 2009 8:27 am  

Iafeta wrote:

Again, where did they lose Rapira to?

He played in last week's trial versus Melbourne. I think you're confusing him with his brother from the Under 20's 2008 team, Steve, who has now gone to North Queensland. Sam, the Kiwis test prop is still with the Warriors.

Swann was hopeless for the last 18 months, and Wiki was running on about 50% for the last half of his contract. He got dropped midway through last season as a result.

Must have got him mixed with Steve then.

: Sun Feb 22, 2009 8:49 am  

Manly will go back to back,I put money on it so they better!