M@islebugs wrote:
Just as an aside, Does anyone have the faintest idea why we signed,
Crossley
Mendieka
Caro
Clare
Ryan
Neilsen
And yet didn't sign Jarrod Sammutt when he was available and we had no halfbacks?
A player who once scored 25 tries in a SL season for us.
I've not read all the threads for a while, but this caught my eye. I agree and I'd also love to know a reason behind this. It has been blindingly obvious from very early on this season that we lacked a good enough scrum half. Addy covered it well enough for most weeks, harry can get away with some of his poor efforts in the championship, but neither was ever going to be a good enough option come the 8's, and so it proved, and yet we found the money to buy more back rowers and wingers. Sammut might not be the worlds best half, but hes better than Addy, Purtell and Harry, and would have given us another dangerous option on Saturday.
Of that list above, I actually rate Caro and Clare, and with Williams thats as good a set of wingers as we can expect in the Championship. Neilsen has been solid enough and I suspect we'll see more from him with a full preseason. Ryan is a good backrower, but we have never been short in the backrow and Id like to see Mellor Pitts Ferguson and Addy in there ahead of Ryan. And as for Mendieka, he was an odd signing and I dont think he is good enough, needs to be moved on.
The scrum half position IMO has been Lowes and Ferris' main failing, and the one area that needs rectifiying before all else next season, the answer might not be Sammut, but it needs to be not Addy/Purtell/Harry. I think Addy is one of our best players, but he needs to go into the backrow, I think Purtell has been brilliant, but he needs to play in the centre...Harry needs to leave.