Goal Kicking : Sun Feb 08, 2015 12:28 pm  

From struggling to find a goal kicker a couple of seasons ago to now having possibly 4 who should kick our goals?

Walsh if fit would be my first choice it's if his injury permits?

Makinson can kick well but misses some easy ones

Burns kicked at HKR don't know what his % was

Percival can kick also

Who would you choose?

Re: Goal Kicking : Sun Feb 08, 2015 12:35 pm  

Rommel wrote:

From struggling to find a goal kicker a couple of seasons ago to now having possibly 4 who should kick our goals?

Walsh if fit would be my first choice it's if his injury permits?

Makinson can kick well but misses some easy ones

Burns kicked at HKR don't know what his % was

Percival can kick also

Who would you choose?

Percy was kicking really well last year and can't beleive we had tommy kicking before him on Friday.

Re: Goal Kicking : Sun Feb 08, 2015 3:00 pm  

Percival would be fine for my fantasy team. But I would think Tommy will be the goal kicker, given that Walsh damaged his leg. He probably does not want to be putting too much force through it yet.

Re: Goal Kicking : Sun Feb 08, 2015 3:14 pm  

bewareshadows wrote:

Percival would be fine for my fantasy team. But I would think Tommy will be the goal kicker, given that Walsh damaged his leg. He probably does not want to be putting too much force through it yet.

Percy really improved his kicking lash year and Id go with him as first choice.

Re: Goal Kicking : Sun Feb 08, 2015 4:04 pm  

I had no Idea Percival was the better kicker. I thought it was makinson. But it seems to be that others agree Percival is the better of the two.

Re: Goal Kicking : Mon Feb 09, 2015 10:05 am  

Out of the 3, I would have Percival & Burns above Makinson...

IMO Tommy isnt reliable and not sure what his % is but would be surprised if it was much above 50%.

Perci kicked 3/3 under the pressure of a GF at OT last year, and had really improved his kicking towards the end of last season (and would probably be my first choice behind Walsh). Burns also kicked regularly for Hull KR last year and came up with some big successes (touchline conversion to make it 24-24 at Huddersfield in the last minute springs to mind) so not sure why Tommy is ahead of both of these at the moment.

Re: Goal Kicking : Mon Feb 09, 2015 3:12 pm  

I have been informed that Tommy kicks them from anywhere in training; must be the match pressure getting to him.