Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 3:27 pm  

With Wello out injured ATM Makinson is doing a good job covering for us?

Question: If he starts the season well and maybe gets on the score sheet should he keep his place when Wello is fit?

I can't see Royce not playing his club Captain but the future looks bright with Tommy, pace to burn maybe needs to bulk up a bit

Re: Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 3:32 pm  

Rommel wrote:

With Wello out injured ATM Makinson is doing a good job covering for us?

Question: If he starts the season well and maybe gets on the score sheet should he keep his place when Wello is fit?

I can't see Royce not playing his club Captain but the future looks bright with Tommy, pace to burn maybe needs to bulk up a bit

If he plays well then he deserves to be there on merit.

I don't think he needs to bulk up though in all honesty, I don't remember seeing him physically dominated. The tackle he did on Kris Welham on our own line against Hull KR in the challenge cup was phenomenal . Welham had about a 10m run at Tommy at full pace and Tommy snapped him in half.

Re: Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 4:59 pm  

He owned George Carmont in the first Wigan playoff game

Re: Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 5:31 pm  

Rommel wrote:

With Wello out injured ATM Makinson is doing a good job covering for us?

Question: If he starts the season well and maybe gets on the score sheet should he keep his place when Wello is fit?

I can't see Royce not playing his club Captain but the future looks bright with Tommy, pace to burn maybe needs to bulk up a bit

If wello don't play at London and whoever plays fullback and plays well should keep his spot. Wello shouldn't just walk straight back in to the side on the back of his past with saints.

I can't make my mind up who I'd pick a fullback and keep changing my mind, I'm also at odds of who I'd pick in the back line. The only players I can make my mind up on in the backs is Gaskell at 6 and shenton at centre.


I don't think makinson needs to bulk up, he's pretty strong with the ball and I've not seen any problems in his defence, the tackle he made on Patrick ah van on Friday night was top class.

Re: Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 5:44 pm  

Makinson in at fullback for me. I wouldn't hesistate. That lad is quality. He needs to be on the pitch gaining valuable experience as much as possible.

Re: Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 5:48 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

Makinson in at fullback for me. I wouldn't hesistate. That lad is quality. He needs to be on the pitch gaining valuable experience as much as possible.

I think I agree but then a fully fit wello is safe as house under the high ball and in defence.

Makinson IMO is the best of the young bunch, hes fast, beats men, clears his line, tackles and looks safe under the high ball.

I'd defo 100% play makinson either Wing or fullback.

Re: Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 7:03 pm  

St pete wrote:

I think I agree but then a fully fit wello is safe as house under the high ball and in defence.

The OP stated that 'if Wello is injured' so my post was in response to there being no Wello to play.

However, if we widen it to include Wello then this season he will be at fullback regardless of Makinson or anybody else. I love Wello and we missed his ability to catch a bomb in the first half but next season I'd like to see Makinson there and not Wello.

Re: Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 7:06 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

The OP stated that 'if Wello is injured' so my post was in response to there being no Wello to play.

However, if we widen it to include Wello then this season he will be at fullback regardless of Makinson or anybody else. I love Wello and we missed his ability to catch a bomb in the first half but next season I'd like to see Makinson there and not Wello.

I love wello, he's been great player and is top laugh off the pitch but his poor kick returns are massive problem for us but does his ability in defence and under the High ball outweigh that?

Re: Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 7:10 pm  

St pete wrote:

I love wello, he's been great player and is top laugh off the pitch but his poor kick returns are massive problem for us but does his ability in defence and under the High ball outweigh that?

Makinson is fabulous under the bomb. He also appears to have good instinct in positioning also. He is fearless when it comes to tackling. He has real, genuine pace. He can read a game and pass well - he set up one try on Friday. He displays good support play - he scored one try on Friday. The man is just turned 20. I think if we keep hold of Wello and risk losing Makinson that would be a terrible shame. Oh, and Makinson can also kick goals, which Wello definitely cannot!

Re: Full Back : Mon Jan 23, 2012 7:12 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

Makinson is fabulous under the bomb. He also appears to have good instinct in positioning also. He is fearless when it comes to tackling. He has real, genuine pace. He can read a game and pass well - he set up one try on Friday. He displays good support play - he scored one try on Friday. The man is just turned 20. I think if we keep hold of Wello and risk losing Makinson that would be a terrible shame. Oh, and Makinson can also kick goals, which Wello definitely cannot!

Why pick wello in front of him then?