If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 11:51 am  

And Lomax isn't fit enough do we go with Moore, Wilkin or Roby in the halves?

A huge decision for Potter to make. I'd personally go with Moore at 7 I think. Decent kicking game and puts his shoulder in. Gives us essentially 7 forwards on the field for the opening skirmishes. I'm not sure we can afford to go with lomax who has had 3 weeks without rugby and I don't want Wilkin moving out of the forwards.

Re: If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 11:52 am  

imo its for the best if eastmond dosnt play as its kinda wasting a slot in the team

Re: If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 11:54 am  

Smith at 7, Wilkin at 6 for me. Wilkin was better overall last night and while he's no halfback, he's used to playing at 6 now and we desperately need to be settled for next week. Potter changed too many people around last night just to facilitate a crocked Kyle (hope he is better and wowing us again next season) and to do that again for a Grand Final would be suicide.

Re: If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 1:24 pm  

Roby and Smith for me. Roby to just run and run, Smith to organise and handle the kicking. Scotty Moore on the bench.

Re: If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 1:58 pm  

Kyle should not be seen until Fenruary ( or a pre season freindly ), end of !

Re: If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 3:06 pm  

No point in playing Kyle.

He will just no doubt get injured again at some point, and in a Grand Final especially, you cannot waste a jersey.

Re: If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 3:09 pm  

Saddened! wrote:

Roby and Smith for me. Roby to just run and run, Smith to organise and handle the kicking. Scotty Moore on the bench.

Thats what i'd have picked last night and would pick next week. We could use roby as a extra forward and leave smith to run the team as he did when wilkin was at 6 against the wolves.

Wilkin is not a stand off in a million years but it worked against wolves as wilkin played as a forward leaving smith to do his thing.

Kyle and smith was a mistake in the halfs, both took a backseat and looked as tho they didn't wan't to step on each others toes.

wello
gardner/lomax
meli
gidley
foster
roby
smith
graham
kc
tony p
sia
flannery
wilkin

bryn
clough
emmitt
moore

That is what i'd go with next week.

Re: If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 3:10 pm  

OoOGazOoO wrote:

No point in playing Kyle.

He will just no doubt get injured again at some point, and in a Grand Final especially, you cannot waste a jersey.

I agree.

Playing both kyle and lomax in any team together looks a risk as none of them ever complete the game.

Re: If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 3:19 pm  

Kyle needs to recover and kick on next year.

Id go with Smith and Roby.
I think Roby should do 80 mins

Moore to replace KC

Re: If Kyle doesn't play next week : Sat Sep 25, 2010 3:23 pm  

saintcj wrote:

Kyle needs to recover and kick on next year.

Id go with Smith and Roby.
I think Roby should do 80 mins

Moore to replace KC