Well that was interesting.
Most of that debate seemed to be around 50% of the game. ie where a man drives in the ball. I'm assuming as most of the play takes place in the centre of the field this also makes Roby a prop too.
However the other 50% of the games is defence. So does this make the halfbacks centres? Where did Sia line up in defence? 2nd Row / Centre or prop??
From what I could gather neither side were accepting of the others opinions hence why we get statements like 'fact'.
Well it's not fact it's an opinion. Whilst I agree 'laughable' could be regarded as insulting, so can things like your 'average fan'.
But generally on here the insults remain within what I would call pub banter. The challenge always comes when you get 2 strong opinions clashing. It was interesting to watch.
In the end it can be argued either way, sure he played some elements of prop, but he also played second row too, maybe that makes him a proprow. But the entire lack of reference to the defensive structure suggest that people were picking elements that best suited their own point of view. Quite frankly if we had 7 players at prop in defence then we would have had people stood behind each other or holding hands in the line up.
As for the original point, my ambitions are for some good RL, some fantastic skill shown from our halves. Top 4 finish and a semi (final) in the CC.
Our worst teams in the SL era finished 5th, so it's a ridiculous post but to be expected.
