Allez wrote:
Have a chat with yourself. Given that you are very quick (and consistent) in your willingness to point out how poorly you feel other players fit the bill for us in the modern game just look at the way Makinson did pretty much everything right on Friday, particularly defensively which is where JF has been poor. Then take a look at the other calamitous efforts Foster showed this year in defence on a number of occasions.
At least be consistent if you're gonna make daft statements driven out of your desire to shift Wellens from FB.
I'm not dIscrediting Foster as he did a decent job for us last year. But even my 7 year old nephew can see than Makinson has far more about him wherever he plays.
I like Makinson, I'd just like to see him at fullback, I don't think he's a natural winger. Possibly centre when he's older I guess. Where did he play in the academy? I bet it wasn't on the wing.
Makinson has the errors in him, look at the try at Widnes by Ah Van and the game-changing mistake against Catalans that was rescued by the video ref being very generous towards us. He is quicker and more athletic, but he seems to go through entire games without doing anything.
Jamie Foster is a very solid winger and one we should keep hold of. His goalkicking is a valuable asset and with his confidence restored under a proper coach he could do very well for us.