Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Thu Sep 18, 2014 11:15 am  

Top Saint wrote:

You're kidding. That won't stop until poor Paul retires.

That's hopeful.

Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Thu Sep 18, 2014 11:57 am  

dede wrote:

IF Hock came to Saints, would it mean you would focus you venom on him and leave poor Wello alone.

You make him sound like a disabled war veteran. In reality he's a highly paid professional sportsman who used to be good 6 years ago.

Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Thu Sep 18, 2014 4:21 pm  

Saddened! wrote:

You make him sound like a disabled war veteran. In reality he's a highly paid professional sportsman who used to be good 6 years ago.

true

Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Thu Sep 18, 2014 6:02 pm  

We haven't had a line busting and offloading second rower since Derek McVey.

Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Thu Sep 18, 2014 6:12 pm  

The Chief wrote:

We haven't had a line busting and offloading second rower since Derek McVey.

He was quality! I'd love somebody like that now.

Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Thu Sep 18, 2014 11:22 pm  

if we sign Hock, the next signing might be Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi if he can play a decent standard of RL.

Sorry, I know that is in very poor taste , but Gareth "Head Banger" Hock - how many games would he miss because of brain farts?

I understand if Mods delete this post; but REALLY Gareth Hock in a Saints shirt, talk about selling your souls to the Devil?

Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Thu Sep 18, 2014 11:28 pm  

Always good to get onside with the mods before posting

Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Thu Sep 18, 2014 11:41 pm  

Saddened! wrote:

You make him sound like a disabled war veteran. In reality he's a highly paid professional sportsman who used to be good 6 years ago.

Yeah true....but what about Wello...??? In reality Hock hasn't shown a sustained run of good form for a few years and coupled with his tendency to get himself in trouble, often not even related with his playing aggression, and his age it would be foolish to take him on for the three or four games a season where he runs riot (against Leigh, Widnes, Wakefield and Salford).

And whomever said that a chairman should take on a player who'd likely help challenges for trophies as much as ruin the club, that philosophy has some merits (Sean Long). But if the said player only has one of those qualities (and not the good one) then surely it'd have to be a no.

Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Fri Sep 19, 2014 11:11 am  

wertyuio wrote:

Yeah true....but what about Wello...??? In reality Hock hasn't shown a sustained run of good form for a few years and coupled with his tendency to get himself in trouble, often not even related with his playing aggression, and his age it would be foolish to take him on for the three or four games a season where he runs riot (against Leigh, Widnes, Wakefield and Salford).

And whomever said that a chairman should take on a player who'd likely help challenges for trophies as much as ruin the club, that philosophy has some merits (Sean Long). But if the said player only has one of those qualities (and not the good one) then surely it'd have to be a no.

I think Hock's ability is unquestionable, he's ripped us to shreds plenty of times. In terms of his on field activities he's exactly what we need to replace Sia and Manu (The decision to not give him a contract is annoying me more and more every day).

Re: Anybody no if hock is coming to you ? : Fri Sep 19, 2014 4:03 pm  

bewareshadows wrote:

Always good to get onside with the mods before posting

Ah, so that's the trick is it?

As for Saint in Wire's post, he's OK as he hasn't made a quip that some goon fans go whinging to the mods that it was in bad taste