Re: Meli, Sia and TP : Sun Jul 03, 2011 8:26 pm  

BackrowSaint wrote:

I know, I've seen him play. I do rate him.

I wasn't comparing what roles they play, I was comparing what their overall game offers to the team.

I'd take waterhouse over any of our backrows with any hesitation.

He'll be great player for Warrington. Only concern is his age but I don't think it will be a problem as he's a very fit player.

I'm looking forward to seeing him in super league, it's a shame it's for them.

Re: Meli, Sia and TP : Sun Jul 03, 2011 8:28 pm  

St pete wrote:

I'd take waterhouse over any of our backrows with any hesitation.

He'll be great player for Warrington. Only concern is his age but I don't think it will be a problem as he's a very fit player.

I'm looking forward to seeing him in super league, it's a shame it's for them.

I would certainly take him over our back rowers if we class TP as a prop, without a doubt.

Re: Meli, Sia and TP : Sun Jul 03, 2011 8:38 pm  

BackrowSaint wrote:

I would certainly take him over our back rowers if we class TP as a prop, without a doubt.

I'm pretty sure he's been a one club player in the NRL so maybe he'll struggle to settle.

Can't see it like but let's hope

Re: Meli, Sia and TP : Sun Jul 03, 2011 10:38 pm  

I have seen a lot more of TP than Waterhouse; I will put it that way. However, I am very optimistic. He will really suit the game played at WArrington and I think he will certainly offer a lot more for WArrington than TP. As I have said, I have always had reservations about TP's work in his own half.

I think this issue may have the potential to turn into a Roby/Monaghan debate and, just like that debate, I think the answer will be horses for courses.

I am staggered as to how you have discovered such a unique and exclusive insight into TP's actions in the transfer areas. However, I don't doubt a word you have said.

Re: Meli, Sia and TP : Sun Jul 03, 2011 11:02 pm  

jdrocket wrote:

I am staggered as to how you have discovered such a unique and exclusive insight into TP's actions in the transfer areas. However, I don't doubt a word you have said.

Oh it wasn't by any insider track or 'reliable sources'.

He came into were I worked and was talking to a mutual friend of mine and his. Luckily I was with him at the time and I asked him, simple as that really.

Re: Meli, Sia and TP : Sun Jul 03, 2011 11:40 pm  

BackrowSaint wrote:

Oh it wasn't by any insider track or 'reliable sources'.

He came into were I worked and was talking to a mutual friend of mine and his. Luckily I was with him at the time and I asked him, simple as that really.

Well that would appear to be a conclusive answer.

Re: Meli, Sia and TP : Mon Jul 04, 2011 12:09 pm  

jdrocket wrote:

Well that would appear to be a conclusive answer.

It certainly turned out that way.