bewareshadows wrote:
Dugan for Perry.
Not to batter a point. But has Dugan ever played as a half???
Do we want another quality fullback to play half back, we've made that error once already.
If a prop goes, do we not need another prop???
I'm all for getting names in, but we also need a balanced side. We are swapped with fullbacks at the moment and just putting a 6 or 7 on their back ain't going to make them a half.
Think of Duggan as being at Jamie Lyon's level. He would be comfortably the best player in Super League. If there is a possibility of getting a player of that quality then IMO you do not pass it up.
He isn't the organising, controlling half we've lacked since Kyle left, but with him at 6 in the same sort of role Leon Pryce had, we would have the most destructive and exciting player in Super League. Wilkin or Hohaia could then do the scheming and we would be significantly improved.
If it were a case of Duggan for one season or Dobson permanent, then I would go with Dobson. But Duggan for 2 years ala Lyon is something we should not pass up if its at all possible. He is an outstanding player.
