Re: Wilkin : Sun Feb 13, 2011 10:21 pm  

St pete wrote:

I'm entitled to have my say on the " chicken wing" tackle like everyone else on this forum.

I think he acted like a OTT footballer trying to get another player sent off which isn't the rugby way. I played rugby for 22yrs at a high level and for my local teams and have never seen of heard any player act in the way wilkin did.

You state I don't like wilkin, that's not true and you should keep untrue comments about what you THINK you know to yourself.

wilkin made a fool of himself crying to the re

He was more focused on watching himself on the big screen all night.

it's no shock that wilkin could kick start this sort off thing.

No, no, you're right. You're Wilkin's biggest fan.

Re: Wilkin : Sun Feb 13, 2011 10:31 pm  

Mr. Phil wrote:

No, no, you're right. You're Wilkin's biggest fan.

I fail to see where i say I don't like him.

I don't rate him but how does that mean I don't like him?

And what's it got to do with you?

Re: Wilkin : Sun Feb 13, 2011 10:32 pm  

He thought he was the victim of an attempted chicken wing, being under 3 tacklers he didn't have the viewpoint of us. He didn't ask for the man to be sent off, he told the ref what he thought. Whether it was a chicken wing it not, Lima was going at his arm in that tackle.

Re: Wilkin : Sun Feb 13, 2011 11:05 pm  

St pete wrote:

I'm entitled to have my say on the " chicken wing" tackle like everyone else on this forum.

I think he acted like a OTT footballer trying to get another player sent off which isn't the rugby way. I played rugby for 22yrs at a high level and for my local teams and have never seen of heard any player act in the way wilkin did.

You state I don't like wilkin, that's not true and you should keep untrue comments about what you THINK you know to yourself.

Ok, I apologise, what I meant to say was; "it would appear evident from your other posts about Jon Wilkin that your opinion of him as a player is extremely low when compared to other professional rugby players... so it comes as no surprise he's putting in his tuppence worth so readily here."

I think Billinge_Lump sums the incident up most accurately.

Re: Wilkin : Mon Feb 14, 2011 10:05 am  

I thought Wilkin and the ref dealt with it well.
He felt a man in the tackle attacked his joint in a dangerous manner, which obvioulsy hurt him. He didn't shout, swear, scream or stamp his feet. He wasn't trying to get a man sent off on the day to gain an advantage (as the ref obvioulsy wouldn't have done this).
He spoke to the ref in a professional manner, who in turn spoke to the captain of the opposition, not the player accused. The event will be reveiwed and if Lima's guilty he'll be charged.

If we're complaining about instances like this, then we're looking for things to moan about imo.

Re: Wilkin : Mon Feb 14, 2011 2:37 pm  

It would appear Wilkin was correct, with Lima being charged with TWO offences!

Re: Wilkin : Mon Feb 14, 2011 8:45 pm  

But one of the charges is of being TP's bitch

Re: Wilkin : Mon Feb 14, 2011 10:06 pm  

As a one-time cheeky half back, I regularly felt let down by the referee failing to punish dirty play - 'it's all part of the game' they'd say as I picked myself up off the floor after getting decapitated in a late tackle.

Well done Wilkin. If he's risked his reputation to try to clean up our game, well done him. Isn't the game hard enough already?

Re: Wilkin : Mon Feb 14, 2011 10:27 pm  

Wilkin has every right to complain to the ref IMO, he felt Lima was out to do him harm as much as tackle him, im all for big hits and collisions but 'chicken wings' and deliberatly trying to injure players needs to be stamped out. Im all for the commitee having a look and if Lima is found guilty ban him. Yes and thats from a Wigan fan.

Re: Wilkin : Tue Feb 15, 2011 9:26 am  

Bill_Barlow wrote:

Wilkin has every right to complain to the ref IMO, he felt Lima was out to do him harm as much as tackle him, im all for big hits and collisions but 'chicken wings' and deliberatly trying to injure players needs to be stamped out. Im all for the commitee having a look and if Lima is found guilty ban him. Yes and thats from a Wigan fan.