Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 1:14 pm  

Hope it doesn't weigh on Tom's mind too much.

Besides his hatrick, what an effort to try and stop that last try.

Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 2:09 pm  

The Yellow Giraffe wrote:

You don't need to be so quick to "defend" Makinson. Nobody is blaming him.

You don't need to be so quick to make jump down my throat. I wasn't defending anyone. I simply expressed my opinion, and frankly that's all it can be from anyone since when did one camera angle tell the full story?

I think it is such a shame that anyone is even writing about this.

Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 2:18 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

You don't need to be so quick to make jump down my throat. I wasn't defending anyone. I simply expressed my opinion, and frankly that's all it can be from anyone since when did one camera angle tell the full story?

I think it is such a shame that anyone is even writing about this.

No one is blaming Tommy he just fell onto the back of Luke's leg chasing back causing the accident (pure accident) you'll probably never see an injury like it again #sic

Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 2:31 pm  

Rommel wrote:

No one is blaming Tommy he just fell onto the back of Luke's leg chasing back causing the accident (pure accident) you'll probably never see an injury like it again #sic

You don't know that he did do that. We've only got one camera angle to make an assessment and even from the one angle we have got, it doesn't look to me like he did.

Of course people are apportioning blame, why else was this scenario even raised as a possibility?

Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 2:37 pm  

Its noones fault, just a freak accident

Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 2:38 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

You don't know that he did do that. We've only got one camera angle to make an assessment and even from the one angle we have got, it doesn't look to me like he did.

Of course people are apportioning blame, why else was this scenario even raised as a possibility?

Absolutely nobody has blamed anyone.

Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 2:50 pm  

BackrowSaint wrote:

Absolutely nobody has blamed anyone.

Looks very much like it to me or else why even raise it?

It's distasteful and totally unnecessary, and not even convincing.

Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 2:59 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

Looks very much like it to me or else why even raise it?

It's distasteful and totally unnecessary, and not even convincing.

You've totally lost the plot here. You're letting yourself down massively.

Nobody has blamed Makinson at all. Somebody said he made contact with Walsh, which nobody is doubting apart from you, and you've got all defensive about it and thrown your toys out of the pram.

Seriously just chill out. Nobody is blaming anyone. We were simply discussing how it happened.

Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 3:08 pm  

The Yellow Giraffe wrote:

You've totally lost the plot here. You're letting yourself down massively.

Nobody has blamed Makinson at all. Somebody said he made contact with Walsh, which nobody is doubting apart from you, and you've got all defensive about it and thrown your toys out of the pram.

Seriously just chill out. Nobody is blaming anyone. We were simply discussing how it happened.

Just listen to yourself.

First of all someone raised this as a possibility. Why?

Secondly, everyone assumed the worst even though we see every week on Sky how different camera angles show a different scenario. Why?

Thirdly, because I disagreed with the post blaming Makinson - and still do - you accuse me of stupid things like getting defensive when actually I was simply disagreeing with the post blaming Makinson. Why?

Someone says Makinson fell on to Walsh's leg and that is what caused Walsh's leg to break, even without conclusive proof of such a scenario, and yet nobody is blaming Makinson? Get real!

I'm not defending anyone because there is nothing to defend. Nobody did anything. Walsh fell over his own feet. I find it distasteful that anyone else is even discussing this. Walsh hasn't even left hospital yet and Makinson is a very good friend of his.

Re: walsh injury : Mon Jul 28, 2014 3:22 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

Just listen to yourself.

First of all someone raised this as a possibility. Why?

Secondly, everyone assumed the worst even though we see every week on Sky how different camera angles show a different scenario. Why?

Thirdly, because I disagreed with the post blaming Makinson - and still do - you accuse me of stupid things like getting defensive when actually I was simply disagreeing with the post blaming Makinson. Why?

Someone says Makinson fell on to Walsh's leg and that is what caused Walsh's leg to break, even without conclusive proof of such a scenario, and yet nobody is blaming Makinson? Get real!

I'm not defending anyone because there is nothing to defend. Nobody did anything. Walsh fell over his own feet. I find it distasteful that anyone else is even discussing this. Walsh hasn't even left hospital yet and Makinson is a very good friend of his.

I guess if Jordan Turner doesn't shoot out of the line it's a simple one on one tackle but these things happen & thank god it's not that often.