Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:35 pm  

Thelonius wrote:

Wasn't going to mention that, but as you have... I suspect Wilkin may have a week off next week, if not the week after too.

Your probably right , I just saw it again and he jumps too which makes it even worse . Gardner's was nowhere near as bad, in fact last year I doubt it would have been a penalty. The RL disciplinary being how it is though (a lottery) who knows

Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:36 pm  

I don't think Meli was looking to kill the player. He just got stepped and flung out an arm.

Whether the injury or ban will be longer is debatable.

All in all, we brought this on ourselves as a team. Get get a penalty from the first kick and stuff it up. Watching that game you would think we do not like the ball. Lance in defense is aweful. I'd say get shut but we have no one left.

The war or whatever has gone on with Gaskell is biting us badly. As we have players playing all over the place.

Unless we can keep the ball we are going to get shot to pieces.

Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:36 pm  

Dux wrote:

Come on . He clothes-lined the guy in the face. Malicious or not, it was a dreadful tackle.

Cant argue it was a crap tackle but I honestly dont think there was any malice in it.

Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:38 pm  

No1 Saint wrote:

Your probably right , I just saw it again and he jumps too which makes it even worse . Gardner's was nowhere near as bad, in fact last year I doubt it would have been a penalty. The RL disciplinary being how it is though (a lottery) who knows

It was a shoulder charge, as was Wilkin's. Both are illegal, both players know this, yet both were idiotic enough to use it. And Gardner had already committed the cardinal sin of coming off the line, so leaving a 10m wide gap for a try to be scored but then that doesn't surprise me either as Gardner has been pants this season.

Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:40 pm  

Classic Greg Eden!!

Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:42 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

It was a shoulder charge, as was Wilkin's. Both are illegal, both players know this, yet both were idiotic enough to use it. And Gardner had already committed the cardinal sin of coming off the line, so leaving a 10m wide gap for a try to be scored but then that doesn't surprise me either as Gardner has been pants this season.

I think you'll find there is a difference to Wilkin's and Gardners . Wilkin went looking for him and got him GArdner was trying to shut down an overlap. I can also assure you Gardner didnt have much of any choice as he was outnumbered , it was rush out or look like a tool just stood still

Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:43 pm  

No1 Saint wrote:

it was rush out or look like a tool just stood still

I like that, for some reason.

On your point about the shoulder charges, they are both on report for shoulder charges so presumably that interfering old goat on the sidelines thought they looked the same. However, Wilkin's did look more aggressive, and wasn't actually even remotely necessary while Gardner's could be justified as per your post.

Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:44 pm  

bewareshadows wrote:

I don't think Meli was looking to kill the player. He just got stepped and flung out an arm.

Whether the injury or ban will be longer is debatable.

All in all, we brought this on ourselves as a team. Get get a penalty from the first kick and stuff it up. Watching that game you would think we do not like the ball. Lance in defense is aweful. I'd say get shut but we have no one left.

The war or whatever has gone on with Gaskell is biting us badly. As we have players playing all over the place.

Unless we can keep the ball we are going to get shot to pieces.

Our best chance is to hope Dobson's injury means he cant carry on or carries on limping round and hope for some more Eden brainfarts

Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:45 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

:lol: I like that, for some reason.

On your point about the shoulder charges, they are both on report for shoulder charges so presumably that interfering old goat on the sidelines thought they looked the same. However, Wilkin's did look more aggressive, and wasn't actually even remotely necessary while Gardner's could be justified as per your post.

Re: 19 man squad named for Hull KR cup tie : Sat Apr 20, 2013 2:48 pm  

Looks like it's not all over!