Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sat Sep 19, 2015 1:06 pm  

Mugwump wrote:

The Wigan fans are consoling themselves because they feel they were the better team. But we're long overdue giving them a good thumping.

To be honest I think they were, we won due to us playing the "Don't Right off the Saints" card. We are not exactly dominating anybody at the moment, a good thumping 80-0 against Wire would be good but those days are long gone.

Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sat Sep 19, 2015 1:56 pm  

How's Haggarty played this season?

Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sat Sep 19, 2015 3:29 pm  

Judder Man wrote:

To be honest I think they were, we won due to us playing the "Don't Right off the Saints" card. We are not exactly dominating anybody at the moment, a good thumping 80-0 against Wire would be good but those days are long gone.

I think a lot of our conservatism can be explained by Cunningham. When push comes to shove - he's a rookie coach. Sure, he could order Longy to devise some kind of all-action gameplan. But that's fraught with danger. And head coaches don't get too many opportunities to fail.

I like the fact that he's adopted a pragmatic style. We aren't a team filled with lean athletes (such as Wigan) so it's important we don't waste our pack's energy reserves.

Our backs don't get a great deal of ball. But what Long & Cunningham have done is emphasize the importance of taking the few chances they get.

As has been pointed out - both Swift & Makinson have terrific strike rates. Turner too.

Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sat Sep 19, 2015 9:07 pm  

St pete wrote:

Isn't a worry that our pack struggling to make meters every week now? The Wigan pack was much better than ours last night and it's happening most weeks.

And yet we won. In fact in the last 2 weeks we've beaten the 2 teams above us in the league. I'd be more worried if I was the coach of a team that played much better than the opposition and still lost, or the coach of "the team that's going to win everything this year".

Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sat Sep 19, 2015 9:43 pm  

Harry Pinner wrote:

And yet we won. In fact in the last 2 weeks we've beaten the 2 teams above us in the league. I'd be more worried if I was the coach of a team that played much better than the opposition and still lost, or the coach of "the team that's going to win everything this year".

This was different to the previous two wins though, we were not dominated by Leeds or Cas; they were more end to end games. If the defence hadn't been so good we would have been mullered by the goons.

I am guessing that the stats show the worst meterage difference for us than at any game this this year, such was the goon pack dominance.

Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sun Sep 20, 2015 3:20 am  

I'm really struggling to see this weakness in our pack. I mean, had our poor figures been solely the result of Wigan (or some other team's pack) mullering us every set I'd see a point. But very often our position, possession - stats etc. are bad for no other reason than silly, stoopid mistakes and sloppy play.

Sure, a 500 meter defecit can mean a pack was physically dominated. But it's just as likely to mean the team kept dropping the ball and making mistakes. For a champion team we don't half make some stupid errors.

What I will say is what I've said all along. With a strong side and the pack playing well I'm as confident as I can be.

Besides, some of Wigan's forward play this season has been utterly abysmal. Just look at their chief yardage makers. The match stats are embarrassing.

Sure, I get that Wane is trying to play a different type of football. But maybe that's just vanity on his part. There's a reason almost no-one in either the NRL or SL has gone down such a route in decades of rugby.

Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sun Sep 20, 2015 8:20 am  

saint at wire wrote:

This was different to the previous two wins though, we were not dominated by Leeds or Cas; they were more end to end games. If the defence hadn't been so good we would have been mullered by the goons.

I am guessing that the stats show the worst meterage difference for us than at any game this this year, such was the goon pack dominance.

It was different, in that we were good in defending our line, but we don't half make it difficult for ourselves. As posters have already mentioned we invite the opposition to come at us so they gain extra metres on each play, when we have the ball we struggle to get out of our own half to put in a pressure kick. If there is a stat somewhere for the team who has to kick out from under the own posts, I can bet Saints are high up in this stat.

The goons were 50% (500 metres) better than us for gaining ground, usually this is with getting the ball to the backs but there was some good metres made by the goon pack in this match. Our pack metres one of the worse this season.

I,m not agreeing with Muggers theory above with dropped ball, mistakes and errors costing us metres, Saints are one if not the best team for the least amount of errors, I think the goons made almost twice as many errors than us in this game. The one thing that stands out like a sore thumb is our discipline especially around the 5th tackle, there is a slight improvement but its still not good enough.

Defending our line won us this game which meant we were only chasing for a one score lead, the win was even more sweeter because Wane thought this game was in the bag for those 75mins, don't write off the Saints must have been ringing in his ears.

Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sun Sep 20, 2015 8:43 am  

Mugwump wrote:

I'm really struggling to see this weakness in our pack. I mean, had our poor figures been solely the result of Wigan (or some other team's pack) mullering us every set I'd see a point. But very often our position, possession - stats etc. are bad for no other reason than silly, stoopid mistakes and sloppy play.

Sure, a 500 meter defecit can mean a pack was physically dominated. But it's just as likely to mean the team kept dropping the ball and making mistakes. For a champion team we don't half make some stupid errors.

What I will say is what I've said all along. With a strong side and the pack playing well I'm as confident as I can be.

Besides, some of Wigan's forward play this season has been utterly abysmal. Just look at their chief yardage makers. The match stats are embarrassing.

Sure, I get that Wane is trying to play a different type of football. But maybe that's just vanity on his part. There's a reason almost no-one in either the NRL or SL has gone down such a route in decades of rugby.

Can you really not see that we struggle to make meters? Only big alex offers any real go foward.

It's clear as day we don't make any real go foward and teams know this. We are at our most dangerous when we are in their line and teams no if they pin us back we struggle as we play a one up rugby style.

The loss of Vea for most of the year hasn't helped as he does offer go foward but if you look at the rest of the pack we have Amor, Richards, Thompson, Mose (he can on his day), Geeenwood, flash, Wilkin and Lms who couidnt break thru a paper bag most weeks and not great in making meters. Sav is still hit and miss due to his age but some weeks HES making no meters either.

I know you have a soft spot for the pack and that's your opionon but in mine it's nothing more than the normal run of the mill pack.

If we don't get a big tough meter making prop in next year to help alex and robes then we will struggle more. It's clear saints feel this as we have been after every prop and his dog for next year.

Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sun Sep 20, 2015 4:32 pm  

Mugwump wrote:

Sure, a 500 meter defecit can mean a pack was physically dominated. But it's just as likely to mean the team kept dropping the ball and making mistakes. For a champion team we don't half make some stupid errors.

We made almost double the amount of errors you did...

Re: Post Match Stats - Goal Line defence Wins the Game : Sun Sep 20, 2015 4:40 pm  

Wigg'n wrote:

We made almost double the amount of errors you did...

We have made less meters than any of the top 6 this year.