Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Sun Aug 02, 2015 11:22 am  

TBH when Warrington have beaten us (Leeds) this season I don't think they've done anything tactically amazing which stopped us. Just think we've been off colour those days and passes didn't stick and they've played with a desperation to win. Ben Westwood will still be banned for them when we play them next week and he's been the key for those two wins leading from the front so he'll be a massive loss.

Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Sun Aug 02, 2015 12:20 pm  

ThePrinter wrote:

TBH when Warrington have beaten us (Leeds) this season I don't think they've done anything tactically amazing which stopped us. Just think we've been off colour those days

Not so generous in defeat, after all.

ROFLMAO!!

Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Sun Aug 02, 2015 5:18 pm  

I remember 2011. We just couldn't beat Wigan. We played them six times that season and we lost the first four, sometimes quite hansomely. But clearly eventually we learned how to play them because we beat them in the play offs: not once, but twice, and by the same score.

Because we came closer this time than the last twice, I'm crossing my fingers that 2015 will be a repeat of 2011 but obviously this time with Leeds.

Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Sun Aug 02, 2015 5:44 pm  

SaintsFan wrote:

I remember 2011. We just couldn't beat Wigan. We played them six times that season and we lost the first four, sometimes quite hansomely. But clearly eventually we learned how to play them because we beat them in the play offs: not once, but twice, and by the same score.

Because we came closer this time than the last twice, I'm crossing my fingers that 2015 will be a repeat of 2011 but obviously this time with Leeds.

It was closer this time but was has been overlooked in Mugwump's clinging onto the 'comeback' Saints made is this......Saints played last Friday, Leeds only on Sunday.

Give Leeds an equal turnaround of 7 days or God forbid Leeds have the 7 day turnaround whilst Saints only have 5 days then how close do you think that Semi Final goes?

Not to mention we went 60 mins without our starting hooker in Aiton. Granted Burrow gives us an excitement factor but we missed Aiton in the middle particularly defensively as Burrow doesn't defend there when on so leaves more work for the forwards in the middle without a 30/40 tackles hooker beside them.

Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Sun Aug 02, 2015 5:53 pm  

ThePrinter wrote:

It was closer this time but was has been overlooked in Mugwump's clinging onto the 'comeback' Saints made is this......Saints played last Friday, Leeds only on Sunday.

Give Leeds an equal turnaround of 7 days or God forbid Leeds have the 7 day turnaround whilst Saints only have 5 days then how close do you think that Semi Final goes?

Not to mention we went 60 mins without our starting hooker in Aiton. Granted Burrow gives us an excitement factor but we missed Aiton in the middle particularly defensively as Burrow doesn't defend there when on so leaves more work for the forwards in the middle without a 30/40 tackles hooker beside them.

Sorry ThePrinter, but that's not really a fair manner of looking at things. The turnaround stuff is neither here nor there - the game is littered with wins for sides with a shorter turnaround and a longer one.

The injuries stuff could easily be twisted (we lost Greenwood and Vea in the game also, you lost JJB as well).

The reality is you beat us and deserved to do so. You could have been out of sight in half an hour, but you weren't regardless of what we say or don't say. We were within 4 of you when Masoe knocked on in your half when we had much momentum. Swings and roundabouts as they say.

The only caveat I'd offer as a Saints fan, is that I honestly do believe Saints have a lot of improvement on the showings we've put up against Leeds this year (if you're interested, check the QUITTING thread where I've listed four), I'm not convinced Leeds can massively improve on the showings you've put in on us.

I've followed Saints for too long to write them off and I won't be doing it this year either. It'll still take a mighty fine effort to knock us over in the Play Offs, especially if we start to remedy some of the issues we've shown against you. However, right now, you're big favourites, no doubt. Again though, arrogantly dismissing us is something I'd be wary of doing as a Leeds fan. Admittedly, our recent history against you gives you a lot of confidence but that comes to an end let me tell you. It was you guys that did it to our legends starting in 2007, the very same could easily happen to yourselves in 2015.

Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Sun Aug 02, 2015 6:09 pm  

SLS wrote:

Sorry ThePrinter, but that's not really a fair manner of looking at things. The turnaround stuff is neither here nor there; the game is littered with wins for sides with a shorter turnaround and a longer one.

The injuries stuff could easily be twisted (we lost Greenwood and Vea in the game also, you lost JJB as well).

The reality is you beat us and deserved to do so. You could have been out of sight in half an hour, but you weren't regardless of what we say or don't say. We were within 4 of you when Masoe knocked on in your half when we had much momentum. Swings and roundabouts as they say.

The only caveat I'd offer as a Saints fan, is that I honestly do believe Saints have a lot of improvement on the showings we've put up against Leeds this year (if you're interested, check the QUITTING thread where I've listed four), I'm not convinced Leeds can massively improve on the showings you've put in on us.

I've followed Saints for too long to write them off and I won't be doing it this year either. It'll still take a mighty fine effort to knock us over in the Play Offs, especially if we start to remedy some of the issues we've shown against you. However, right now, you're big favourites, no doubt. Again though, arrogantly dismissing us is something I'd be wary of doing as a Leeds fan. Admittedly, our recent history against you gives you a lot of confidence but that comes to an end let me tell you. It was you guys that did it to our legends starting in 2007, the very same could easily happen to yourselves in 2015.

Not dismissing Saints' chances but it doesn't alter the results between us so far.

To ignore the turnaround thing is kind of head in sand stuff though. To claim their's a equal list of short turnaround wins neither holds up or highlights not every one of those will be a game between 1st vs 2nd in a cup semi final. You can't honestly believe an extra two days rest for Leeds (or even two days less for Saints) wouldn't alter a thing about the game?

As for the injuries. You get a 2nd rower get injured then you roll another 2nd row on in a straight swap. Aiton who defends in the traditional hooker position in the middle making 30/40 tackles goes off and the 'replacement' in Burrow comes on and defends next to Hall and everyone has to move in one. Imagine Roby going off and his replacement has to defend out wide, what effect would that have on your props not having Roby (or a replacement) to defend with them in the middle? Very significant indeed.

Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Sun Aug 02, 2015 6:22 pm  

ThePrinter wrote:

Not dismissing Saints' chances but it doesn't alter the results between us so far.

To ignore the turnaround thing is kind of head in sand stuff though. To claim their's a equal list of short turnaround wins neither holds up or highlights not every one of those will be a game between 1st vs 2nd in a cup semi final. You can't honestly believe an extra two days rest for Leeds (or even two days less for Saints) wouldn't alter a thing about the game?

As for the injuries. You get a 2nd rower get injured then you roll another 2nd row on in a straight swap. Aiton who defends in the traditional hooker position in the middle making 30/40 tackles goes off and the 'replacement' in Burrow comes on and defends next to Hall and everyone has to move in one. Imagine Roby going off and his replacement has to defend out wide, what effect would that have on your props not having Roby (or a replacement) to defend with them in the middle? Very significant indeed.

You've beaten us fair and square on all three occasions.

I do believe the extra day or two is a red herring. I've seen us win Grand Finals after a fortnight off, I've seen us win without it. I've seen us lose to teams with a shorter turnaround and win in similar situations etc. Sure, in theory you'd have less energy but I think in games like this, adrenaline takes over. Second half, you were kicking to touch a lot anyhow because the manner in which you start games saps plenty from you.

Injuries, yeah they matter a lot. It's no excuse anyway, they happen and we get on with it. Vea was a huge loss in that particular game. He's quickly become a big part of our set up. I think we've only really recognised just how big he is for us in the couple of games since he's been back (and now gone). Like for like in theory but it takes something away.

Nevertheless, you won, we didn't. You deserved it. Good luck to you for the final and hopefully, we'll get another shot at you later in the season.

Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Sun Aug 02, 2015 7:41 pm  

SLS wrote:

You've beaten us fair and square on all three occasions.

I do believe the extra day or two is a red herring. I've seen us win Grand Finals after a fortnight off, I've seen us win without it. I've seen us lose to teams with a shorter turnaround and win in similar situations etc. Sure, in theory you'd have less energy but I think in games like this, adrenaline takes over. Second half, you were kicking to touch a lot anyhow because the manner in which you start games saps plenty from you.

Injuries, yeah they matter a lot. It's no excuse anyway, they happen and we get on with it. Vea was a huge loss in that particular game. He's quickly become a big part of our set up. I think we've only really recognised just how big he is for us in the couple of games since he's been back (and now gone). Like for like in theory but it takes something away.

Nevertheless, you won, we didn't. You deserved it. Good luck to you for the final and hopefully, we'll get another shot at you later in the season.

Phil clarke on sky looked into the short turnaround thing and said the evidence shows that the short turnaround doesn't hinder anyone. He went into his usual crap with stats etc to come to the conclusion

Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Tue Aug 04, 2015 1:25 pm  

I think leeds and saints are the best two teams in the league . That does not mean either Leeds or Saints are guaranteed to win anything .
Wigan can play a spoiling game and upset the applecart. We played well last Friday and deserved our victory. If we played you at old trafford I would think it would be anybody's game.
So the answer to your question, yes you can beat Leeds. From a rugby point of veiw a Leeds -Saints grand final would suit me, we would see a decent game conducted in good spirit, as per last Friday .
Fingers crossed it will not feature Wigan .

Re: Will we beat Leeds in 2015? : Tue Aug 04, 2015 1:43 pm  

Backwoodsman wrote:

I think leeds and saints are the best two teams in the league . That does not mean either Leeds or Saints are guaranteed to win anything .
Wigan can play a spoiling game and upset the applecart. We played well last Friday and deserved our victory. If we played you at old trafford I would think it would be anybody's game.
So the answer to your question, yes you can beat Leeds. From a rugby point of veiw a Leeds -Saints grand final would suit me, we would see a decent game conducted in good spirit, as per last Friday .
Fingers crossed it will not feature Wigan .

The thing is we haven't learnt our lessons from the 3 encounters, we have the worse half backs and full back in super league for defence, Leeds just ran across the line until eventually they came across these 3 players and went through the turnstiles.
We are reasonable against teams below us but a poor second when we play Leeds, we could play Leeds 5 times this season but its the last one that counts.