Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Thu May 23, 2013 7:04 pm  

Billinge_Lump wrote:

Hohaia to full back to replace Wellens, then maybe Clough in for Perry. Otherwise keep the same team as last week.

Spot on.

I'm certainly no fan of HiHo but Ashe seems very poor.

Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Thu May 23, 2013 7:38 pm  

Would put Forster in for Perry and have Josh sent to Formby were he should spend the weekend running over sand dunes till he throws up.

Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Thu May 23, 2013 7:43 pm  

I agree about Ashe he does not inspire me. More of the George Michael than the George Nicholls

Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Thu May 23, 2013 7:53 pm  

I wouldn't let Ashe near the u19s, never mind the first team.

Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Thu May 23, 2013 8:01 pm  

Think I will personally count how many times Ashe touches the ball. I will only need one hand.

Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Thu May 23, 2013 9:48 pm  

From that 19, I can see Ashe playing as it balances out the side. If you drop Ashe, suddenly you are having to move Percy from Centre and Makinson from Wing.

Leave Ashe in and let Lance organise the defensive line from FB.

If it was a different 19, then you may drop Ashe, but not from that line up.

Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Fri May 24, 2013 7:06 am  

bewareshadows wrote:

From that 19, I can see Ashe playing as it balances out the side. If you drop Ashe, suddenly you are having to move Percy from Centre and Makinson from Wing.

Leave Ashe in and let Lance organise the defensive line from FB.

If it was a different 19, then you may drop Ashe, but not from that line up.

It doesn't balance the side out, it gives us a unfair disadvantage as we will be playing with 12 and Warrington will have 13.

Ashe IMO is one of the worst players to put on a saints shirt. He's shocking in defense and offers nothing at all in attack. I'd rather play blackbrooks stand off than him and I'm not messing.

Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Fri May 24, 2013 7:09 am  

St pete wrote:

It doesn't balance the side out, it gives us a unfair disadvantage as we will be playing with 12 and Warrington will have 13.

Ashe IMO is one of the worst players to put on a saints shirt. He's shocking in defense and offers nothing at all in attack. I'd rather play blackbrooks stand off than him and I'm not messing.

Have to agree, I see absolutely nothing from him at all

Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Fri May 24, 2013 9:21 am  

St pete wrote:

Ashe IMO is one of the worst players to put on a saints shirt. He's shocking in defense and offers nothing at all in attack. I'd rather play blackbrooks stand off than him and I'm not messing.

The way moon just walked past him for Leeds' second try was embarrassing.

Re: 19 Man Squad v Warrington Magic Weekend : Fri May 24, 2013 11:56 am  

St pete wrote:

It doesn't balance the side out, it gives us a unfair disadvantage as we will be playing with 12 and Warrington will have 13.

Ashe IMO is one of the worst players to put on a saints shirt. He's shocking in defense and offers nothing at all in attack. I'd rather play blackbrooks stand off than him and I'm not messing.

Dya think he would have been better playing for haven on loan for a full season in the championship