Seems a big step up between under 16s to under 19's
I appreciate at present that we see some of the best under 16's sometimes being moved upto under 18's and also under 18's going into reserve competition.
However going forward we may be talking about 15 year olds being asked to play against 19 year olds.
I seem to recall back in the 1980's when i was a nipper, that something like that happened at Blackbrook when the Blackbrook Royals under 14's/15's played a match against a so called French school side, that actually put out 18/19 year olds.
The result was a bloodbath as the French "laid on" the Blackbrook kids. Parents of the blackbrook lads were naturally livid at seeing their sons take a hammering.
Such things can damage the reputation of a sport. If parents think RL isnt prepared to protect their children, and instead wants to throw them to the lions then many parents will just say no to letting their kids play RL. Promising kids themselves can also have their confidence literally smashed out of them by older and not necessarily as talented players.
What is also going to happen with the reserve competition. Is that going to stay, or will players be chucked on the scrap heap at 19 years old. Most players only really start to break into first teams at around 21 years of age. Hence if we bin off the reserves then we will pretty much be killing off any player development.
I like the idea of utilising championship clubs or even championship 1 teams as psuedo feeder teams for the SL clubs.
This would in many ways follow the australian model.
The best juniors who arent quite ready for the rigours of SL would be able to play at a higher level than reserves and thereby be able to polish their games off. It would also have the benefit of raising the quality and profile of the RL in the championship. Rather than ignoring the championship as most SL fans do now, we would instead see fans of Wigan, Warrington and St.Helens, keeping a close eye on reports coming out of Leigh, Swinton or Oldham to see who their new superstar player may be. Fans of Leigh, Swinton or Oldham would also get to see first hand the burgeoning talents of the new Jonny Lomax or Sam Tomkins.