Re: Walmsley, England and Man of Steel : Thu Sep 24, 2015 10:22 am  

jaybs wrote:

Players yes pick it,l but then there is a panel! a lot of fans will be slightly biased here, I still think Walmsley has a lot to learn and develop his game still, not yet a Man of Steel.

What does he need to learn? How to be even further ahead of everyone else in the league for carries, metres made and tackle busts than he already is?

Re: Walmsley, England and Man of Steel : Thu Sep 24, 2015 10:37 am  

jaybs wrote:

Players yes pick it,l but then there is a panel! a lot of fans will be slightly biased here, I still think Walmsley has a lot to learn and develop his game still, not yet a Man of Steel.

Why are the majority of your posts leaning towards garbage, the very fact that professional players have selected him says a lot more than your unbalanced weak opinion of him.

Re: Walmsley, England and Man of Steel : Thu Sep 24, 2015 10:47 am  

Dux wrote:

To be fair, you did win a few of those titles from outside the top 2-3. The MOS will tend to be a player from a team that's been consistent over the whole season. I can understand the frustration, though - it does seem slightly out of kilter. For what it's worth, I suspect you'll have a winner this time.

Point taken, but I can't remember Cas being the most consistent side three times since 1999.

Re: Walmsley, England and Man of Steel : Thu Sep 24, 2015 11:00 am  

tony1983 wrote:

Point taken, but I can't remember Cas being the most consistent side three times since 1999.

No, obviously it doesn't apply every time. But in fairness they were right up there last year when Clarke won it, and when Rangi Chase won it he was the obvious candidate. Adrian Vowles, admittedly, is the one that sticks out.

Re: Walmsley, England and Man of Steel : Thu Sep 24, 2015 4:28 pm  

St pete wrote:

I think they got the right there players on the shortlist this year. All three are worthy winners but Imo Id go with walmsley

Wouldn't begrudge any of these guys tbh , personally I would go with Hardaker , he has been different class at times this season , even when the team has underperformed he hasn't . what may count against him is the well documented off field indiscretions