Re: Tommy Makinson - Hands Off! : Thu Feb 19, 2015 8:54 pm  

redex113 wrote:

4 year deal!!!! is he that good?

Simple answer.

Re: Tommy Makinson - Hands Off! : Thu Feb 19, 2015 9:13 pm  

If Makinson were in the NFL he'd be All Pro.

Re: Tommy Makinson - Hands Off! : Sat Feb 21, 2015 12:55 pm  

I'm glad tommy is staying as he's a good player and a lad I like. His attitude is top class.

I also think he's not the finished article yet. His finishing is world class. His defence is as good as any winger in the world. He's safe under the high ball (slightly dodgy back end of the year). He looks for work but my only gripe with Tommy is that he doesn't beat many men. That's the only weakness I can think off which he can work on.

I thought he really stood up in the grand final. His performance in that game went pretty unnoticed but that try saving tackle on Liam Farrell (I think it was) was every much a match winner.

Re: Tommy Makinson - Hands Off! : Sat Feb 21, 2015 2:04 pm  

St pete wrote:

I'm glad tommy is staying as he's a good player and a lad I like. His attitude is top class.

I also think he's not the finished article yet. His finishing is world class. His defence is as good as any winger in the world. He's safe under the high ball (slightly dodgy back end of the year). He looks for work but my only gripe with Tommy is that he doesn't beat many men. That's the only weakness I can think off which he can work on.

I thought he really stood up in the grand final. His performance in that game went pretty unnoticed but that try saving tackle on Liam Farrell (I think it was) was every much a match winner.

Thought he was man of the match in the grand final. His covering defence was top class.

Re: Tommy Makinson - Hands Off! : Sat Feb 21, 2015 2:05 pm  

The Reaper wrote:

Thought he was man of the match in the grand final. His covering defence was top class.

I had him in my top 3.