Re: England Knights : Fri Oct 04, 2013 11:47 am  

wakey_saint wrote:

I'm surprised Swifty hasnt made this squad as well as Makinson, think he must have pushed close on his performances this season

I think it would have been difficult to justify swifty in the line up.

He has had a blistering end to the season, but it's hard to put up a case that given the number of games he should go straight in.

Re: England Knights : Fri Oct 04, 2013 1:14 pm  

bewareshadows wrote:

I think it would have been difficult to justify swifty in the line up.

He has had a blistering end to the season, but it's hard to put up a case that given the number of games he should go straight in.

He also didn't actually do very much. Any winger can fall over the line to score provided they can catch a ball. The fact that he scored so many wasn't that remarkable. I still don't think he's a winger either, just doesn't look natural for him there.

Re: England Knights : Fri Oct 04, 2013 2:26 pm  

Saddened! wrote:

He also didn't actually do very much. Any winger can fall over the line to score provided they can catch a ball. The fact that he scored so many wasn't that remarkable. I still don't think he's a winger either, just doesn't look natural for him there.

Constantly bagging our yound lads. Dident do very much ? he scored a couple of full length tries (something you moaned we never did) and made a number of full length breaks (again something you always critizised we never did).

Seen u bagging our young forwards on another thread saying they 'dont do much' these lads (richards and Thompson) are 18 years of age. What was Peacock doing at 18 ? you constantly write absolute balls and i aint biting because you aint trolling. You just dont know much about Rugby league and what it involves.

Re: England Knights : Fri Oct 04, 2013 3:00 pm  

Saddened! wrote:

He also didn't actually do very much. Any winger can fall over the line to score provided they can catch a ball. The fact that he scored so many wasn't that remarkable. I still don't think he's a winger either, just doesn't look natural for him there.

Getting a bit tiring now, stick to the funny stuff once in a while.

Re: England Knights : Fri Oct 04, 2013 3:05 pm  

Now now (Saddened) don't drag me in on this bagging everything St Helens.

I thought he has plenty of class on the wing.

My point is selection for internationals would be tough to justify after having such a late run in the side and only 12 games all season.

His try scoring is undoubted, but I think to justify a call up, you need to get a good 12 months under your belt.

You would have to be Murphesque to get a call up after 12 appearances.

But his stats are amazing 13 tries in 12 games. Not bad at all, if he had been there all season he would have been our top try scorer no doubt about it.


Wingers are there to score tries, he has also showed his brains anyone who saw his take on the free play at Hull can see that.

Re: England Knights : Fri Oct 04, 2013 6:55 pm  

BJB scored an 80 mtrs interception try at Wigan in the League game four weeks ago. Seemed to have plenty pace then.
The only thing is that he does appear to have had a few injuries and his early season illness..
A Leeds fan I know would prefer BJB to Briscoe. Easy to see why IMO.
BJB can also play fb and many Leeds fans think that's his best position.
I'd rather he go to Saints than to London Irish that I read somewhere.

Re: England Knights : Sat Oct 05, 2013 9:24 pm  

Cant say I'm happy about Lomax playing in some pointless sh*tty second string fixture when he should be rested ahead of a good pre season.

Re: England Knights : Mon Oct 07, 2013 2:49 pm  

Albion wrote:

Agreed.

I disagree, surely to represent your country should be the pinnacle of your career. Not to mention that JL will be getting paid, who would compensate him?