Re: Thoughts on Tonight : Sat Mar 13, 2010 10:35 am  

Saint Simon wrote:

I wish you'd stop holding back and just say what you think

Hi simon, ive been holding back for last 3yrs about wilkin. I know people think i got something against him but i don't.

He had everything to be top class(even world class) but he is nothing more than a squad player IMO. He wouldn't get in the top super league sides.

I can't fault his work in defense but with ball in hand he is shocking. All i hear is how well he runs his lines but its wearing thin now.

Gilmour was still twice the player wilkin was when we let him go.

Re: Thoughts on Tonight : Sat Mar 13, 2010 10:59 am  

Wilkin was a different class last night

Re: Thoughts on Tonight : Sat Mar 13, 2010 7:43 pm  

St pete wrote:

I'm not being funny but i'm sick to death of hearing how well wilkin runs good lines!!!!

He never makes a break so them good lines he's running must be wasted because of our passing

I've avoided saying this for last 3yrs but fook it, wilkin is 2nd rate player who is not good enough for saints anymore. Since the likes of scully, joynt, and few other stars have left he's now showing he was being carried.

I can't fault he defensive efforts but thats all he is, his attacking is shocking for a player who they say has all the skills. IMO he's behind flannery, clough, tony p in the backrow.

Flannery ain't much better to be honest.

For a player that never makes a break, he did well to make that break early on to set up Roby's try.