Re: 2022 | Injuries & Suspensions : Fri Jul 01, 2022 12:55 pm
Magic Superbeetle wrote:
Hurrell1 - absolutely fine. Leeds fans booed, but it was clear Martin fell off before Hurrells ball carrying arm hit the ground.
Walmsley1 - absolutely fine, not even sure what you could claim was wrong in the build up
Fusitu'a - Incorrect. There have been stills shown he was out, but even that should have been a penalty to Leeds, Grace fell on him as his ball carrying arm was on the ground completing the tackle. Grace had no right to try and drag him out, and Fusitu'a had no right to pass it, either way, no try.
Grace - I know there is nothing I can say that will convince you he had control of the ball, even though he was gripping the ball on the inside of his wrist. The angle which would have shown if there was separation had a Leeds foot in the way, but your all acting like he goofed up - one thing to note is after the ball was on the ground he definitely had control of it, because Bentley tried to rip it out and failed.
Hurrell2 - absolutely fine. If you are going to complain about Martin taking Paasi out the play before, I will point out Welsby literally stops waiting for the referee who correctly points out no ones been obstructed before the play continues.
Thompson - is as dodgy as the Grace try as far as I am concerned - Handley knocks it forward as far as I see.
Paasi - Absolutely fine. Again I am not sure what you could claim as an issue in the build up.
Batchelor - Absolutely fine. Was a lovely run and pass by Lomax to boot. Only thing would be Bentley falling late into Batchelor, but that just led to more chants from the home fans.
Norman - Absolutely fine. Only thing the ref missed in the build up was the crusher tackle by Newman on Bennison.
Walmsley2 - Absolutely fine. Only thing is the ref should have sin binned Leeming for a professional foul (and thats according to the sky commentary team) and a sin bin for Newman going off on the ref (but thats ground already covered).
Which ones are you disputing? And as a wider point how many games have you been to where a team has 4/5 tries ruled out? Should you all not be concerned that Saints props scored 4 of their tries against you, including one who had never scored for the club before (Paasi) rather than desperately looking for anyone but the team to blame for the scoreline?
Walmsley1 - absolutely fine, not even sure what you could claim was wrong in the build up
Fusitu'a - Incorrect. There have been stills shown he was out, but even that should have been a penalty to Leeds, Grace fell on him as his ball carrying arm was on the ground completing the tackle. Grace had no right to try and drag him out, and Fusitu'a had no right to pass it, either way, no try.
Grace - I know there is nothing I can say that will convince you he had control of the ball, even though he was gripping the ball on the inside of his wrist. The angle which would have shown if there was separation had a Leeds foot in the way, but your all acting like he goofed up - one thing to note is after the ball was on the ground he definitely had control of it, because Bentley tried to rip it out and failed.
Hurrell2 - absolutely fine. If you are going to complain about Martin taking Paasi out the play before, I will point out Welsby literally stops waiting for the referee who correctly points out no ones been obstructed before the play continues.
Thompson - is as dodgy as the Grace try as far as I am concerned - Handley knocks it forward as far as I see.
Paasi - Absolutely fine. Again I am not sure what you could claim as an issue in the build up.
Batchelor - Absolutely fine. Was a lovely run and pass by Lomax to boot. Only thing would be Bentley falling late into Batchelor, but that just led to more chants from the home fans.
Norman - Absolutely fine. Only thing the ref missed in the build up was the crusher tackle by Newman on Bennison.
Walmsley2 - Absolutely fine. Only thing is the ref should have sin binned Leeming for a professional foul (and thats according to the sky commentary team) and a sin bin for Newman going off on the ref (but thats ground already covered).
Which ones are you disputing? And as a wider point how many games have you been to where a team has 4/5 tries ruled out? Should you all not be concerned that Saints props scored 4 of their tries against you, including one who had never scored for the club before (Paasi) rather than desperately looking for anyone but the team to blame for the scoreline?
Like I said I have not had the benefit of watching the full game again.
However the actual completion of some of those I have disputed came from play before the act of scoring.
In other words like Hardaker having the ball stolen in a 2 man tackle that led to a try would if the ref got it right not have stood.
Other examples have already been made and I`m not going over them again.
Don`t worry we are deeply concerned how our pack gets owned time and time again.
We have been rebuilding that pack for several years now and the likelihood is it will take a couple more years to get it right.
At the end of the day the score line says you won comfortably.
We will agree to differ how good a game Grant had on the day.
Pleased to read that he is not going to spoil another game this weekend though.
