[Wildthing]

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 9:48 am  

Westerman had a poor game with regards to defence, but Tomkins was great to watch from a neutral perspective, dont get all the hate for him. I think he's a great talent!

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 9:57 am  

john1962 wrote:

u cas fans r just idiots,when a big fat forward smacks a kid off the ball,an u lot says its ok,well lets hope u get kick out of the super league,cause u r all a set of w........,u will b replace by widnes, the rugby league dont need scum like u set of b......ds,

In English?

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:07 am  

Fully wrote:

In English?

I think (and I'm knowledgeable on this one) that I'd regard Feka as fat, certainly not Sarge.

Look at your own players, at least Sarge did it in the open (not that clever), Wigan have two players who do this consistently, and sneekily, Coley and O'Loughlin.

With my knowledge of foreign languages, I think I managed to translate

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:16 am  

jonh wrote:

No you do not hear a word about him because he does not beat teams on his own.

This thread is pathetic.

Sargent is a player i would love at Wigan but he targeted Tomkins with a cheap shot and hit him clean. Tomkins took it and i am not surprised it took a bit of time to recover from came back and put in a match winning performance.

Apart from scoring 3 tries not sure what he did to annoy the Cas fans, can somebody please explain?

If anything i would say myler does more to win games on his own than tomkins, as myler has a poorer team around him. Tomkins is partnered with a good halfback in looloo, but myler gets stuck with smith who is poor imho.

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:21 am  

seems very much like a pointless and sour topic tbh, tomkins demolished us from the back of great forward play i dare say had tomkins and coley not played we probably could have won that game,

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:22 am  

Sam tomkins had a great game last night, not sure about 3 world class tries the 1st and 3rd could have been scored by anyone, the 2nd was pretty good though. I'm gunna have another look at the sarge tackle but it did look like he went down like a sack of spuds from a perfectly ok tackle from where i was stood. hope this isnt the start of diving creeping into our game.

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:26 am  

to be fair there was nothing ok about it.

id be surprised if sarge plays against quins

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:33 am  

tropical1 wrote:

to be fair there was nothing ok about it.

id be surprised if sarge plays against quins

Like i say i havent seen the replay yet but to me it just looked like a hard but fair challenge.

And they dont have it on the replay, hopefully be on boots and all.

[Wildthing]

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:34 am  

pyeman wrote:

Like i say i havent seen the replay yet but to me it just looked like a hard but fair challenge.

It looked like cheap afters to me ....

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:37 am  

pyeman wrote:

a perfectly ok tackle from where i was stood.

Spot on.

A big shot with the shoulder...However Tomkins didn't have the ball.

Also, if a prop performaned a ''perfectly ok tackle'' on a halfback the size of Tomkins, how could Tomkins possibly be accused of diving?