Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Thu Mar 04, 2010 12:21 pm  

Speedy wrote:

No thanks

Why? he's a pretty good scrum half, home grown etc.

Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Thu Mar 04, 2010 2:25 pm  

but hes not half the playerhe was when he left here which would taint my image of him the first time round!

Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Thu Mar 04, 2010 2:27 pm  

tigersteve wrote:

but hes not half the playerhe was when he left here which would taint my image of him the first time round!

I always thought he has been pretty good for quins, he had a bad time at wigan but that was more to them playing him wrong than him as a player.

Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Fri Mar 05, 2010 1:52 am  

Danny Orr is half the player Sherwin is. People probably won't accept that, but it's true...

Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Fri Mar 05, 2010 7:32 am  

pyeman wrote:

Why? he's a pretty good scrum half, home grown etc.

We need a good young SH, someone who will last us for years, anothe chase type player would be nice

Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Fri Mar 05, 2010 9:37 am  

Gazemous wrote:

Danny Orr is half the player Sherwin is. People probably won't accept that, but it's true...

Skill wise you are right but at least he has 2 good legs!

Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Fri Mar 05, 2010 4:48 pm  

Speedy wrote:

We need a good young SH, someone who will last us for years, anothe chase type player would be nice

Unfortunatley young top notch scrum halfs, that are willing to sign for a team not challenging for trophies are as a rare as hens teeth and would cost money we cant afford. rangi was a gem of a find but unfortunatley those are quite rare.

Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Fri Mar 05, 2010 5:03 pm  

Rangi chase was all down to adrian vowles.
Maybe adrian can keep a look out for another young half back over in oz.

Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Fri Mar 05, 2010 5:49 pm  

sherwin is well past his best...even at the dogs his game was erratic and full of injury's towards the end.....dont forget he was playing behind a pack which included mason,o'meley,grimaldi,ryan and he still struggled at times.......... if a half-back cannot perform with them infront of you then he never will...

Re: Sherwin Replacement 2011? : Fri Mar 05, 2010 7:04 pm  

berro's best mate wrote:

sherwin is well past his best...even at the dogs his game was erratic and full of injury's towards the end.....dont forget he was playing behind a pack which included mason,o'meley,grimaldi,ryan and he still struggled at times.......... if a half-back cannot perform with them infront of you then he never will...

And Sonny Bill Williams.