In my limited historical knowledge, I would go Rudder, but then again, I would like to be as "crap" as him and had his career! Bad timing for us I think.
Matt Whitaker in the recent past seemed to have least natural talent, though then again, he has made a career playing the game - I aint! Then again from the stands I never missed a tackle or dropped a ball!
And an honourable mention to Paul Newlove - this was one of those occasions where every single person knew he was well past it and wouldn't make a serious contribution and we were all right, though he was class before he rolled up at Cas - that said, that's most people's first negative reaction that whoever we sign, so it was going to be proved right sometime!