Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 10:53 am  

But you really can't see a points deduction or every team would be searching the archives for some such misdemeanour.

Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 10:56 am  

I didnt watch the game so i don't understand wether or not it was likely to have affected the final outcome.
But this is another catastrophe during a Halibut refereed game.
Some action must be taken by the RFL against the referee and salford, what that should be i am undecided.
My main consern is that clubs are not allowed to make this a bad habit like the water carrier or physio that spends half the game on the pitch coaching.
Give some clubs an inch...

Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 11:10 am  

I'm a reds fan and if true we should lose the points especially as it was when you were camped on our line. Personnel change but professionalism remains the same.

Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 11:18 am  

Salford had 14 men on the field for 3 of Castleford's plays at the Salford line according to our complaint to the RFL.

Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 11:22 am  

I can not believe how inept the running of our sport is.

Can you imagine a football team having twelve players on for the last few minutes?

Actually, this happened in football in an FA cup tie I believe between Fulham and Southampton.

one team had a man sent off, and a sub came on in his place. The team won, but were later removed from the cup and the other team re-instated.

Although you cannot compare sports, and taking into account my bias, I believe the points should either be shared or awarded to Cas.

Whether intentional or not, this was indeed cheating and the game void

Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 11:30 am  

Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 11:49 am  

DAVE@CAS1990 wrote:

I can not believe how inept the running of our sport is.

Can you imagine a football team having twelve players on for the last few minutes?

Actually, this happened in football in an FA cup tie I believe between Fulham and Southampton.

one team had a man sent off, and a sub came on in his place. The team won, but were later removed from the cup and the other team re-instated.

Although you cannot compare sports, and taking into account my bias, I believe the points should either be shared or awarded to Cas.

Whether intentional or not, this was indeed cheating and the game void

Compare that to when a team in OUR Challenge Cup played a inelligable player, erm nothing happened!!!
Our game is a joke, therefore nothing will happen (Prediction!)

Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 11:51 am  

Hughies sister wrote:

Thats funny that!!

Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 11:59 am  

Hughies sister wrote:

There is even a guy taking a throw-in at the bottom!! There wasnt a football match happening at the same time was there?

Re: 14 players! : Wed May 01, 2013 12:33 pm  

Wilde 3 wrote:

There is even a guy taking a throw-in at the bottom!! There wasnt a football match happening at the same time was there?

Its a line out you fool!!
Thus enabling the signing of any Sale players not in requirement on 18 minth contracts.
It was all part of Nobbys master plan to entice RU players, making them think RL was just the same 15 man a side game!!!
Genius!!!!